What's at Stake
Two transgender women are suing the Illinois Department of Vital Records for refusing to change the gender marker on their birth certificates because they had reassignment surgery outside of the United States.
For more than four decades, Illinois had permitted individuals who have gender confirmation surgery (sometimes known as sex reassignment surgery) to change the gender “marker” on an original birth certificate. The Illinois Department of Vital Records, however, started interpreting the law to provide this option only if an individual has the surgery performed by a United States-licensed physician.
This created an unnecessary and unfair burden for the growing number of persons who select a surgeon from Europe, South America, or Asia. Both of the women in Kirk v. Arnold opted — for their own reasons — to have their gender confirmation surgery in Thailand.
Kirk v. Arnold argued that denying these women – and others who face the same discrimination – the ability to secure a new, accurate birth certificate not only created everyday challenges that are unnecessary and dangerous, but it was antithetical to the advice of medical experts who recommended that persons who transitioned their gender identity ensure that all aspects of their lives reflect that gender identity. An accurate birth certificate is important not only in those situations where an employer may require a birth certificate to start a new job, but also – especially under REAL ID proposals approved by Congress — may be necessary in the future to secure identification to drive a car, enter a federal building or board an airplane.
The plaintiffs were represented by lawyers from the ACLU of Illinois, the ACLU’s LGBT Project and pro bono counsel from the Chicago office of Jenner & Block.
The State of Illinois changed its policy regarding transgender persons who choose a non-U.S.-licensed surgeon and provided accurate birth certificates to our plaintiffs. The state said it will revise its policy for determining how much surgery must be completed prior to a gender marker change will be revised, but that revision has not yet occurred. The ACLU continues to monitor any arbitrary denials of birth certificates.
Privacy statement. This embed will serve content from youtube.com.
Please note that by playing this clip You Tube and Google will place a long-term cookie on your computer. Please see You Tube’s privacy statement on their website and Google’s privacy statement on theirs to learn more. To view the ACLU’s privacy statement, click here.
Kirk v. Arnold - Response to Motion to Dismiss
Date Filed: 08/03/2009
Kirk v. Arnold - Amended Complaint
Date Filed: 04/07/2009
Reversing Two Restrictive Policies, Illinois Issues Accurate Birth Certificates To Three Transgender Persons
Women Ask Court to Order New Illinois Birth Certificates Following Sex Reassignment Surgery Abroad