Back to News & Commentary

In Illinois, Doctors Refusing to Treat Women Who've Had Abortions

Allie Carter,
ACLU of Illinois
Khadine Bennet,
ACLU of Illinois
Share This Page
August 19, 2010

(Originally posted on RH Reality Check.)

Mid-morning on Friday, after meetings at the Hope Clinic and the East Side Health District (more on these soon), Khadine and I finally turned our wheels onto the road home to Chicago.

It was a beautiful morning. We passed trucks carrying squash and trucks carrying cows. We saw endless fields of corn along I-55, and hundreds of wind farms popping up across the countryside. And we felt good — glad of the work we had accomplished over the 11 day road trip, and glad to be returning home to our families and our own beds.

Then we hit the first construction zone. And then another. We stopped for gas, and ran into another traffic jam. We stopped at the Cozy Dog Drive Inn in Springfield, in the hopes that a lunch break would lead to clearer roads ahead.

At the Cozy Dog.

But it didn’t. If anything, there was more construction on I-55 north of Springfield than south of it. Near Bloomington the traffic slowed to a standstill. We pulled off at the nearest rest stop and switched drivers.

It didn’t seem to help. As we approached the Chicago outskirts, traffic bottlenecked and stopped. “Construction next 2 miles” signs became “Construction next 8 miles.” It was incredibly frustrating to face so many roadblocks, when all we wanted was to be at home after 11 days on the road. But then, roadblocks and obstacles were the persistent, never-ending theme of our entire voyage — so perhaps it was only appropriate that we faced a few ourselves on the road home.

Every place we visited in Illinois -from Rockford to Carbondale, and from the Quad Cities to Champaign-Urbana — told us that Illinoisans face numerous obstacles in accessing reproductive health services and information. Teens aren’t learning how to make healthy decisions and protect themselves, women can’t reliably get access to birth control, emergency contraception or abortion, and those who decide to parent or place their infant for adoption cannot find the support they need to facilitate those decisions.

I want to focus in, however, on one particularly disturbing obstacle that was mentioned in city after city: doctors refusing to care for women who have had abortions. Mind you, these are not doctors refusing to perform abortions. What we heard, in three separate communities, was that there are doctors who refuse to perform routine post-abortion check-ups or even to provide care for completely unrelated ailments to women who previously had abortions. What’s worse, in two instances, we heard that these doctors were some of the few who were accepting Medicaid patients at all — meaning that poor women would have to face greater obstacles to receive needed medical care. In one instance, we heard of a doctor throwing a patient’s medical records on the ground and storming out after he learned she had had an abortion.

Doctors are, of course, entitled to their own personal beliefs. But doctors also have an obligation not to let those beliefs interfere with their patients’ access to medical care. Patients shouldn’t be turned away simply because the doctor disapproves of the personal decisions the patient and her family have made — especially in places like rural Illinois where a doctor’s refusal to see a patient can mean a long wait to find another provider and a long distance to travel to get the care she needs.

The end!

In the end, Khadine and I overcame our obstacles and arrived home Friday after 2,573 miles and 11 days on the road. We hope the information we gathered will help others in Illinois overcome the obstacles they face in accessing reproductive health care and information. We will continue to share their stories in the weeks ahead.

The ACLU of Illinois embarked on a project to put a human face on the status of reproductive health and access to care in Illinois. Over 10 days in July and August, we traveled the state, listening to women, men, young people and doctors throughout Illinois as they share stories about the barriers they face in accessing and providing reproductive health care and information. As we traveled more than 2,000 miles, through 13 Illinois cities and towns, we learned more about the challenges everyday people face in filling prescriptions for birth control, in finding doctors who will provide needed services, including abortions, in dealing with Medicaid funding or in receiving comprehensive, age-appropriate sexual health education in public schools.

You can follow along at or on twitter and facebook.

Do you have a story to tell? We’re listening. Email us at or visit

Learn More About the Issues on This Page