Back to News & Commentary

Inconvenience v. Illegality

Gabe Rottman,
Legislative Counsel,
ACLU Washington Legislative Office
Share This Page
May 14, 2007

And the Chicago Tribune picks up on the oral arguments tomorrow in the DC Circuit on Justice's petition to limit access to counsel for the Gitmo detainees. Great point here:

As for the claim that the attorneys feed information to the media, that's correct -- and, provided they're not leaking government secrets, it's appropriate. The lawyers are the main source of information about the detainees. Their firsthand accounts constitute a big share of the public's knowledge about Guantanamo Bay.Justice is blurring the distinction between an attorney leaking classified information and one simply giving the media a firsthand account of life at Gitmo. The first is illegal. The second is just inconvenient for the government.

Learn More About the Issues on This Page